The Vanderbilt Cup Races on Long Island: America’s First Great Road Races, 1904 to 1910

Written By :

Category :

Classics

Posted On :

Share This :

Crowd watching as W.K. Vanderbilt Jr.'s Mercedes race car starts at the 1908 Vanderbilt Cup on Long Island
Classics

–

The Vanderbilt Cup races on Long Island were America’s first great international auto races. William K. Vanderbilt II started them in 1904, and they ran on public roads in Nassau County, and later partly on his private Long Island Motor Parkway, in 1904, 1905, 1906, 1908, 1909 and 1910. Huge crowds lined the roads, European factory teams came over to race, and George Robertson’s win in 1908 in a Locomobile was the first for an American car. Spectators kept getting hurt and killed, and after two riding mechanics died in the 1910 race, the Cup left Long Island’s public-road courses.

If Indianapolis is the church of American racing, the Vanderbilt Cup was the tent revival that came before it. It was loud, dangerous, a little lawless, and for a few years it was one of America’s most prominent motoring spectacles. Here’s how it went, plus a couple of the New York racers and tracks that grew up around it.

Crowd and race officials around the cars at the start of the 1914 Vanderbilt Cup in Santa Monica, California
The start of the 1914 Vanderbilt Cup at Santa Monica, California. Ralph DePalma won it in a Mercedes. Photo: Bain News Service, George Grantham Bain Collection, Library of Congress, no known restrictions on publication.

How the Vanderbilt Cup Started

William Kissam Vanderbilt II, a great-grandson of Cornelius Vanderbilt, was a serious car guy with a serious bank account. He’d set speed records himself, including one on the beach at Ormond and Daytona in 1904 in a Mercedes. He wanted to get American carmakers into racing, so he put up a big trophy and organized an international road race at home.

The first Vanderbilt Cup ran on October 8, 1904, on a course of about 30 miles of public roads in Nassau County. Plenty of locals hated the idea and tried to stop it in court, and politicians held hearings on it. It ran anyway. George Heath, an American living in Paris, won in a Panhard. The next two went to Darracqs: Victor Hémery won in 1905, and Louis Wagner won in 1906.

The trophy itself is something to see, at least in photos. It’s sterling silver, two feet tall, and shows Vanderbilt driving his record-setting Mercedes at Daytona in 1904. The Henry Ford records that Vanderbilt gave the cup to the Smithsonian in 1934.

Crowds on the Course

The problem was the crowd. Tens of thousands of people came out to watch, and they stood right at the edge of the road and wandered onto it to see the cars coming. In 1906 the race was stopped when the crowd overran the course, and a spectator named Curt Gruner was killed.

There was no race in 1907. Vanderbilt’s answer was to build his own road. The Long Island Motor Parkway was a private, paved, banked highway with bridges over the crossroads, and it was among the world’s earliest limited-access automobile roadways. Construction started in June 1908, and the first 10-mile section opened on October 10, 1908, just in time for that year’s race.

1908: Old 16 and the First American Win

The Long Island race returned on October 24, 1908, using both the new parkway and public roads.

The car to watch that day was a Locomobile built in Bridgeport, Connecticut. It had a 990-cubic-inch four-cylinder engine making about 120 horsepower, and it had already been through one Vanderbilt Cup: in 1906, Joe Tracy drove it to win the elimination race for American cars and set the fastest lap in the Cup itself, with Al Poole riding as his mechanic. In 1908 it wore No. 16, with George Robertson driving and Glenn Ethridge as riding mechanic.

Robertson was 23. He grew up around his father’s garage in New York and had been racing since about 1904. They had a flat tire on the final lap, changed it with their last spare, and still won by 1 minute and 48 seconds, averaging 64.4 mph over about 258 miles. It was the first time an American car won the Vanderbilt Cup. The car has been called “Old 16” ever since, and it’s on display today at The Henry Ford museum in Dearborn, Michigan, in the Driven to Win exhibit.

Harry Grant won the next two, in 1909 and 1910, driving an ALCO.

1910 and the End of Road Racing on Long Island

The 1910 race was the last one on Long Island. Louis Chevrolet’s Marquette-Buick crashed near Hicksville, and his riding mechanic, Charles Miller, was killed. Another riding mechanic died that day as well. The fatalities and renewed criticism brought the Long Island public-road era of the Cup to an end. I go into Chevrolet’s side of it in our post on Louis Chevrolet’s racing career.

The Cup moved around after that: Savannah in 1911 (Ralph Mulford, Lozier), Milwaukee in 1912 (Ralph DePalma, Mercedes), then California. The Santa Monica photo near the top of this post shows the start of the 1914 race, where on February 26 DePalma won in a Mercedes and beat Barney Oldfield’s Mercer by about a minute and 20 seconds after nearly four hours of racing. Dario Resta won in 1915 at San Francisco and in 1916 at Santa Monica. The name came back to Long Island in 1936 and 1937 at the new Roosevelt Raceway, and George Robertson, the 1908 winner, managed that track.

The Tracks: Brighton Beach and Sheepshead Bay

New York had a second racing world going at the same time, on the horse tracks. Brighton Beach in Brooklyn had been a Thoroughbred track since 1879. In 1908 the New York Legislature passed the Hart-Agnew Law, which banned betting on horse races, and the track turned to car racing to stay alive.

Al Poole driving a Simplex race car past the grandstand during a 24-hour race at Brighton Beach, Brooklyn
Al Poole in a Simplex during a 24-hour race at Brighton Beach, Brooklyn. The photo is undated. Photo: Bain News Service, George Grantham Bain Collection, Library of Congress, no known restrictions on publication.

Brighton Beach became known for 24-hour races, where teams of drivers ran around the clock on a one-mile dirt oval. That’s Al Poole in a Simplex above, the same Al Poole who rode with Joe Tracy in Old 16. In July 1909 he and George Robertson won the Brighton Beach 24-hour together in a Simplex, covering 1,091 miles. In May 1910, Poole won it again in a Simplex, this time paired with Charles Basle, with 1,145 miles. Louis Chevrolet and his brother Arthur were in that race in Buicks and dropped out early.

Not far away, Sheepshead Bay was another horse track that went to cars. It was rebuilt as a board speedway in 1915 and ran car races until 1919. A lot of the photos of that era, including Louis Chevrolet in a Sunbeam in 1916, were taken there.

Joan Newton Cuneo, Long Island’s Racing Pioneer

Joan Newton Cuneo seated behind the steering wheel of a racing car
Joan Newton Cuneo at the wheel of a racing car. Photo: Harris & Ewing, Library of Congress, no known restrictions on publication.

One of the best drivers from that New York scene was a woman from Long Island. Joan Newton Cuneo was born on July 22, 1876, in Holyoke, Massachusetts, and lived on Long Island with her husband, Andrew. Her riding mechanic for years was a neighbor named Louis Disbrow, hired by her husband to keep her cars running.

The AAA tried to keep her out of the 1905 Glidden Tour, a long-distance reliability run, because she was a woman. She pointed out that nothing in the rules said women couldn’t enter, and she drove it in a White steamer. In 1908 she finished the Glidden Tour with a perfect score in a Rainier.

Her best moment came at the New Orleans Fair Grounds in February 1909. She entered nearly every race, beat Bob Burman and George Robertson, the man who’d won the 1908 Vanderbilt Cup, and finished second to Ralph DePalma in a 50-mile race. Soon after, the AAA banned women from sanctioned racing. Cuneo kept setting unofficial records in non-AAA events and campaigned for better roads. She died on March 24, 1934.

1904: a race with traffic problems built into its stopwatch

The Henry Ford’s artifact-based history of the Vanderbilt Cup makes the first race more interesting than a simple finish-order list. The triangular course measured 30.24 miles, and the cars made ten laps. Yet the competition distance was 284.4 miles, not the straightforward product of those two numbers. The missing distance belonged to control sections through populated areas.

At Hicksville and Hempstead, the cars had to stop at designated control points. Each carried a box for papers recording arrival and departure times. Officials subtracted the control time from elapsed time when calculating the result. A surviving drop box in the museum’s collection turns that abstract timing rule into an object a reader can actually inspect.

That arrangement tells me how awkward the bargain was. Organizers wanted a major motor race, but they were using roads that still served towns, farms and everyday travel. Neutralizing particular sections did not convert the entire route into a closed modern circuit. Nor did a prestigious sponsor make the risks disappear at the next corner.

The railway crossings are an even sharper example. The museum describes four crossings on the 1904 course, with only one separated by a bridge. Flagmen warned drivers about approaching trains at the others. A race car and a train could therefore have competing claims on the same piece of ground. Grade separation later mattered for a concrete reason, not simply because elevated bridges looked impressive in photographs.

Heath’s Panhard beat seventeen other entrants and averaged 52.2 mph. The museum gives his time as five hours, twenty-six minutes and forty-five seconds. Once he finished, spectators swarmed the road and officials ended the race for safety. The problem of people treating the course as accessible public space was present at the very first event, before the much-discussed 1906 crowd failure.

The riding mechanic was part of the car’s operating system

Period photographs can make the second person in the cockpit look like a passenger. The museum’s account of Glenn Ethridge’s work in the 1908 Locomobile says otherwise. While Robertson drove, Ethridge worked an air pump to pressurize the gasoline tank and operated plungers that pumped oil to the engine. His work helped keep the machine running.

That is a useful way to read the phrase “driver-mechanic team.” It described more than two names entered together. Some tasks that later drivers could take for granted demanded active attention from a second person. Their shared result depended on keeping the car supplied and dealing with trouble far from a modern enclosed pit garage.

The distinction also changes how the casualties should be remembered. Charles Miller and Matthew Bacon were working members of their teams, not unnamed spectators who happened to be near the road. The first Cup had already cost another riding mechanic his life: Carl Mensel, riding with George Arents in the Mercedes that overturned on the second lap of the 1904 race.

According to the Henry Ford account, Arents attempted a turn with a flat tire, the front wheel buckled, and the car rolled. Arents survived his injuries; Mensel died. This was not a sport that only became dangerous in its final Long Island season. The fatal consequences were visible from the beginning, alongside the commercial excitement.

1905 and 1906: the Americans had to qualify before they could challenge Europe

The international contest was not merely a crowd of American entrants against one visiting favorite. In 1906 an American Elimination Trial selected five representatives, and twelve cars contested that trial. The Henry Ford lists Oldsmobile, Pope-Toledo, Thomas, Maxwell, Haynes and Locomobile among the participating American manufacturers. An aspiring team first had to survive its own selection race.

Tracy and Poole’s Locomobile won that trial. The museum’s collection includes the program and the manufacturer’s subsequent advertising. Locomobile promptly used the result to proclaim itself the builder of “the greatest American car.” That is a contemporary sales claim, not a neutral ranking we need to adopt today. It shows how quickly a racing result became marketing material.

The Cup itself exposed the difference between being quick and completing the whole job. Tracy and Poole set the fastest lap at a 67.7-mph average, but flat tires and the time lost changing them left them tenth. Their overall average was only 52.3 mph. A single brilliant lap could not repay repeated stops during a 297-mile race.

French-built cars won all three early Cups: Panhard in 1904, then Darracq in 1905 and 1906. Hémery averaged 61.5 mph in 1905; Wagner averaged 61.4 mph the following year. Those close figures should not be treated as a controlled comparison of the cars. The course changed, and the 1906 route had been altered partly to avoid a new trolley line.

The 1906 race also provides a caution about famous firsts. The museum describes its checkered finish flag as said to be the first used to end an American automobile race. I would preserve that qualification instead of turning it into an absolute worldwide invention claim. The surviving album is strong evidence for its use at this event, even if the larger priority claim needs care.

The parkway was an infrastructure project, not simply a longer racetrack

Howard Kroplick and Al Velocci’s Motor Parkway history dates the company’s incorporation to December 3, 1906. Vanderbilt was president; A. R. Pardington became its general manager. The interval before construction was not idle time between canceled and resumed races. Securing a private right of way brought delays and missed milestones.

Vanderbilt presented the proposed road as a convenience for automobile owners and an investment, not solely a speedway. His published vision included a private right of way, railway and road crossings eliminated by bridges or tunnels, fencing, and controlled access through toll gates. The sporting emergency had produced a much broader idea about how motoring might work.

There was a commercial contradiction inside that vision. A road free of ordinary cross traffic could appeal to wealthy motorists, but the company still needed land, construction money and paying customers. The later history of reduced tolls and competition from free parkways belongs to the same story as the banked corners. Engineering ambition did not guarantee a profitable business.

The October 10, 1908 Motor Parkway Sweepstakes were also practical preparation. The historical account says the races tested the new road, course, timing arrangements and crowd control before the Cup on October 24. The first opening was therefore not identical to completion of the entire eventual road. Only a little more than nine miles of the proposed route had been built in 1908.

1908: why nine miles of new road did not make the whole course private

The Henry Ford gives the Cup circuit as 23.46 miles: nine miles of parkway and 14.46 miles of public roads. Seventeen cars made eleven laps. Calling the race a Motor Parkway event is fair; imagining the cars circulating solely on Vanderbilt’s purpose-built pavement is not. Most of the lap still lay outside the new roadway.

The new features nonetheless changed the experience. Bridges separated traffic streams, guardrails helped manage spectators, and overpasses offered places to watch. Supply pits in front of the Hempstead Plains grandstand allowed crews to pass fuel, oil and tires to the competitors without blocking the spectators’ view. The museum connects those literal pits with the enduring language of the pit stop.

Locomobile also changed the serviceability of its car. Improved tires and demountable rims addressed the very weakness that had spoiled its 1906 challenge. On the final lap in 1908, Robertson and Ethridge still suffered a flat, but they could replace it with their last spare and continue. The result illustrates preparation and repair time, not just a large engine’s power.

Robertson’s route to the victory had been uneven. The museum records an engine failure during his attempt to qualify in 1905 and a car destroyed in practice after he qualified for 1906. Put those setbacks beside Tracy’s tire troubles and the 1908 win stops looking like an effortless breakthrough. Several seasons of frustrated attempts came first.

Nor was the national contest neatly divided by drivers’ passports. American drivers could enter European-built machinery. The museum identifies E. J. Kilpatrick in the French Hotchkiss and Herbert Lytle in the Italian Isotta among the 1908 field. “First American car to win” is a statement about the winning machine’s origin, not a claim that the earlier winners lacked American connections.

1909 and 1910: a shorter lap brought the cars back to the crowd more often

Kroplick and Velocci describe a 12.64-mile circuit for the final two Long Island Cups, shorter than the earlier layouts. Organizers wanted shorter intervals between the cars’ appearances and a more engaging spectacle. The Motor Parkway still formed only part of that loop. A photograph of a car on the new pavement cannot establish that its entire lap was isolated from the old roads.

Harry Grant and riding mechanic Frank Lee won both years in the ALCO. Those consecutive American-built victories extended the achievement of Old 16, but competitive success did not answer the safety question. In 1910 the speed and prestige of the event again collided with the way the course and its surroundings were managed.

The specialist history’s account of the 1910 criticism identifies Bacon as Harold Stone’s mechanician in the Columbia that went over the Newbridge Avenue Bridge. Miller died in Chevrolet’s separate accident. Several spectators were injured. Keeping those events distinct avoids converting the final day into a vague story in which every victim was struck in the same crash.

The New York World’s editorial cartoon showed the Grim Reaper presenting the trophy to the winning ALCO. That is evidence of the contemporary reaction as well as an example of sensational newspaper imagery. I do not need to pretend the cartoon was a balanced accident investigation to see what it communicated: the race’s public reputation could no longer be separated from its casualties.

After the race left: the road kept changing

The parkway did not close when the Cup left Long Island. It continued as a toll road and expanded. Kroplick and Velocci describe western and eastern extensions, further toll entrances and a later western extension in Queens. Different dates and lengths in road histories can therefore refer to different stages of a changing network, not necessarily to incompatible measurements of one finished 1908 road.

John Russell Pope designed toll lodges with living accommodation for the collectors. The detailed history describes offices, kitchens, living rooms and upstairs bedrooms in the early lodges. These were staffed gateways, not modern unmanned toll gantries. The road’s controlled access had a small domestic world attached to it.

The company also commissioned Pope to design the Petit Trianon Inn at Lake Ronkonkoma, drawing on the French building’s restrained classical appearance. The inn served the affluent motoring clientele and later operated under other owners before its destruction by fire in 1958. It belongs to the road’s leisure-travel history rather than the Cup’s race results.

Eventually the Depression and an expanding free parkway system undermined the toll road. The specialist account dates its closure to April 17, 1938, and describes transfer of the right of way to public authorities in exchange for cancellation of back taxes. Some sections became public roads, some a Queens bicycle path, and others disappeared or found new uses.

How I would read the surviving evidence

Start with an artifact, its date and its caption. A 1914 Santa Monica starting photograph illustrates the Cup after Long Island; it is not a photograph of Robertson’s 1908 victory. A 1906 program may explain the trial rather than the main race. A car built in 1906 can correctly be the famous winner of the 1908 event. Those distinctions are small, but they stop a visual history from quietly sliding between years.

Crowd numbers should remain estimates, especially along miles of public road. The sources cited here give differing large estimates for the same era; they are not turnstile counts. Likewise, retain the measured distance and course beside an average speed. A lap average, a full-race average and a beach speed record answer different questions.

That is why I find the museum’s timing box, advertisements, programs and photographs so valuable together. They show administration, commerce, maintenance and spectatorship alongside the winning car. The Vanderbilt Cup was a racing breakthrough, but it was also an argument over who could use the road, how spectators could be protected, and what an automobile-only route ought to become.

FAQ

Where was the Vanderbilt Cup race held?

From 1904 to 1910 it ran in Nassau County on Long Island, New York, first on public roads and then partly on the Long Island Motor Parkway. Later races were held in Savannah, Milwaukee, Santa Monica and San Francisco, and it returned to Roosevelt Raceway on Long Island in 1936 and 1937.

Who won the first Vanderbilt Cup?

George Heath, driving a Panhard, on October 8, 1904.

Why did the Vanderbilt Cup races on Long Island end?

Crowd control was always a problem, and spectators were killed. Two riding mechanics died in separate accidents in 1910, and the fatalities and criticism ended the Cup’s Long Island public-road era.

What was the first American car to win the Vanderbilt Cup?

The Locomobile “Old 16,” driven by George Robertson in 1908. It’s on display at The Henry Ford in Dearborn, Michigan.

Can you still drive the Long Island Motor Parkway?

Parts of it. The parkway was closed in 1938, but some sections survive as pieces of other roads and as a bike trail.

If you want more early racing, read why Indianapolis is called the Brickyard or the story of the Blitzen Benz and its 141 mph run at Daytona.

Sources

Featured image: Start of W.K. Vanderbilt Jr.’s Mercedes, Vanderbilt Cup, October 24, 1908. Bain News Service, George Grantham Bain Collection, Library of Congress, no known restrictions on publication. Photos in this article come from the Library of Congress, are in the public domain or carry no known restrictions on publication, and are credited in each caption.

Load More – – –




Pontiac Rageous, the 1997 Forgotten Concept We Want

The 1997 Pontiac Rageous: Where Muscle‑Car Swagger Met Everyday Usefulness Concept cars are usually built to spark conversation… not haul plywood; the Pontiac Rageous did both. Revealed on January 7, 1997, at the North American International Auto Show in Detroit and later paraded before crowds in Chicago, the low‑slung, four‑door hatchback tried to answer a…