EVs Plunge In Value: Study Uncovers Cars with Best Resale

Electric Cars Plummet In Value While Trucks And Hybrids Demonstrate Remarkable Resilience

In a groundbreaking study conducted by iSeeCars, the depreciation rates of over 1.1 million vehicles sold between November 2022 and October 2023 were analyzed, revealing significant insights into the automotive market’s resale value landscape. The study delves into how various vehicle segments, including electric cars, trucks, hybrids, and SUVs, hold their value over a five-year period. We brake down the cars with best resale value from All-Electrics like the Mustang EV to Luxury Sedans like Mercedes.

Electric Vehicles: The Worst Performers

Electric vehicles, known for their eco-friendly nature, face a significant challenge when it comes to holding their value over time. The study reveals that electric vehicles have the highest depreciation rate among all vehicle segments, standing at a staggering 49.1% over five years. This rate is more than 10 percentage points higher than the average depreciation rate for vehicles in general. This stark difference highlights a major issue for electric vehicle owners, as it suggests that their investment in environmentally friendly transportation may not pay off financially in the long run. Several factors contribute to this trend, including concerns about the cost of replacing batteries, the limited availability of charging infrastructure, and ongoing advancements in electric vehicle technology. As the automotive industry continues to transition towards electric vehicles, addressing these challenges is crucial for building consumer confidence and ensuring the sustained growth of the electric vehicle market.

Trucks and Hybrids: Resilient Performers

In contrast to electric vehicles, trucks and hybrids shine as beacons of resilience in the automotive resale landscape. Trucks, renowned for their versatility and utility, boast an impressive depreciation rate of only 35% over five years. Some of the top trucks, like the Toyota Tacoma, lost about 20%. Similarly, hybrids, known for their fuel efficiency and eco-conscious design, demonstrate remarkable value retention, with a depreciation rate of around 37%. This standout performance underscores the enduring popularity and demand for these vehicle types in the used car market. It is also a reason why pickups tend to be named cars with best resale year after year. Consumers continue to value trucks for their rugged reliability and capability, making them sought-after options for a wide range of tasks, from daily commuting to hauling heavy loads. Similarly, hybrids offer a compelling blend of fuel efficiency and environmental consciousness, appealing to drivers who prioritize sustainability without sacrificing performance. As the automotive industry evolves, trucks and hybrids stand as pillars of stability in an ever-changing market, offering reassurance to owners and investors alike.

Sports Cars, Small SUVs, and Economy Cars Shine

However, perhaps not surprising, the big winner in all of this turned out to be the Porsche 911. Both the 911 and the 718 Cayman proved to weather depreciation the best. The 911 only dipping a mere 9% topping our list. In fact, several segments within the automotive market showcase exceptional value retention, offering a glimmer of hope amidst the fluctuating landscape of vehicle depreciation. Sports cars, small SUVs, and economy cars stand out for their resilience in holding their value over time. Iconic models like the Porsche 911, Jeep Wrangler, and Honda Civic lead the charge, embodying the enduring appeal of performance-oriented vehicles and fuel-efficient models among consumers. This trend speaks to the unwavering demand for vehicles that strike a balance between exhilarating driving experiences and practicality, catering to diverse consumer preferences and driving habits. As these models continue to command attention in the used car market, they reinforce the notion that timeless design, exceptional performance, and fuel efficiency remain key considerations for savvy car buyers seeking long-term value and satisfaction.

Luxury SUVs and Sedans: Value Erosion

On the flip side, luxury SUVs and sedans face notable challenges in maintaining their value over time, showcasing substantial value erosion compared to the industry average. Prestigious models such as the Maserati Quattroporte and BMW 7 series bear the brunt of this trend, experiencing depreciation rates that surpass the industry average. Some loosing almost half thier value. Despite their opulent features and prestigious branding, these luxury vehicles struggle to preserve their space in the used car market, highlighting the inherent risks associated with high-end, non-sport automotive investments. As consumers weigh their options, the allure of luxury may be tempered by the reality of significant depreciation, prompting a shift in purchasing priorities towards vehicles that offer a more favorable balance of performance, reliability, and long-term value retention.

Pandemic’s Impact:

The pandemic-induced disruption in new car production and constrained used car supply has had a profound impact on the automotive market. While all cars are holding their value better in 2023 compared to 2019, the average 5-year depreciation has decreased to 38.8%. However, the disparity between vehicle segments remains evident, with electric vehicles bearing the brunt of depreciation.

Expert Insights On Cars With Best Resale Value:

Karl Brauer, the executive analyst at iSeeCars, underscores a notable trend in the automotive market: while the value retention of used cars has improved overall compared to five years ago, disparities exist among different segments. In particular, Brauer points out that trucks and hybrids emerge as standout performers in terms of retaining their value over time. These segments exhibit robust resilience in the face of depreciation, reflecting the enduring popularity and demand for such vehicles among consumers. However, Brauer highlights a contrasting scenario for electric vehicles, noting a significant lag in their value retention compared to trucks and hybrids. This discrepancy underscores the challenges facing electric vehicles in the used car market, signaling a need for deeper analysis and understanding of the factors influencing their depreciation dynamics. As consumers navigate their vehicle purchase decisions, Brauer’s insights provide valuable guidance for identifying segments that offer optimal value retention, ultimately empowering buyers to make informed choices aligned with their preferences and budgetary considerations.

TL;DR What Are The Cars With Best Resale Value?

The study’s findings provide valuable insights into the dynamic nature of the automotive market and the myriad factors that shape vehicle resale value. The iSeeCars study, analyzing over 1.1 million vehicles sold from November 2022 to October 2023, provides insights into the automotive market’s dynamics and factors influencing resale value. It reveals electric vehicles as the worst-performing segment, depreciating by 49.1% over five years, while trucks and hybrids show resilience with depreciation rates of 35% and 37%, respectively.

As consumers, we navigate the complex landscape of vehicle purchase decisions, gaining a nuanced understanding of the depreciation dynamics across different segments. This becomes essential. By comprehending how various factors such as vehicle type, brand reputation, market demand, and technological advancements influence resale value, consumers can make informed choices that align with their preferences and budgetary considerations. Armed with this knowledge, you as a car buyers can optimize your long-term ownership costs and maximize the value proposition of the investment, ensuring a satisfying and financially prudent automotive ownership experience.

Methodology:

iSeeCars meticulously analyzed over 1.1 million used cars from model year 2018, filtering out heavy-duty trucks and vans, discontinued models, and low-volume vehicles. The study employed inflation-adjusted MSRPs from 2018 to 2023 to ascertain the vehicles’ depreciation rates accurately, providing invaluable insights into the automotive resale value landscape.

Note To Reader: Car Nut Chronicles is reader supported. We may post content which contains links to affiliate sites such as Amazon where we may earn a small commission. This helps us keep the lights on and the articles you enjoy being produced. Thank you for your readership, we appreciate you!